Animal Testing: Right or Wrong?

    Animal testing is a very controversial and debatable topic, but what do we really know about it, and how do we really feel about its usage? For clarification: animal testing for cosmetic purposes has already been banned in the European Union, yet it is still allowed in the United States.

    Now, it isn’t hard to at least understand why some people might be pro-animal testing when it comes to the medical reasons. It could save human lives. But is that really true? There are huge differences between humans and the animals that the products are tested on. For example, animals don’t develop the human AIDS syndrome. So, the use of animals for AIDS medications has been useless. Even though these differences do exist, there have been significant research benefits from using animal testing in the past.


    What makes the usage of animals for cosmetic purposes ethical, though? Would getting some new mascara on the market really be that important? Maybe not. If these companies don’t test the products correctly, though, there could be drastic consequences, and the products could be dangerous. However, this isn’t to say that testing is ethical.

    It seems that there are some good reasons why animal testing could be used, right? However, there are also very sufficient alternatives to animal testing, believe it or not. One is in-vitro testing. People volunteer cell samples, and scientists make growth cultures from the samples. Products could be tested on that. There are also computer models that can predict the way in which the human body would react to a certain product.

    For my Social Science Research class this year, my group did a project on whether or not people thought animal testing was ethical. When surveyed, a little over half of the participants thought that animal testing for medical purposes was ethical. Barely 15% of the participants thought that animal testing for cosmetic purposes was ethical. It’s obvious, then, that people think animal testing  is more ethical if done for medical purposes.

    The interesting part about the collected data was the fact that the percentage of people who thought that animal testing should be allowed (for either purpose) was higher than the percentage of people who thought that animal testing (for either purpose) was ethical. Clearly, people believe that animal testing should be allowed despite the questionable morals surrounding it. If someone close to you is sick and needs a medicine that has been tested on animals, it becomes more personal and causes people to value the testing to a greater extent.

    I have two dogs and a cat. I cannot imagine purposefully doing anything to the three of them that would hurt them. The trust and love that they give to me is something that I cannot betray. And it’s not just about my beloved pets, but about other animals, who have feelings, too. I cannot justify hurting an animal, even a lab rat, for something a trivial as a face cream. My resolve does become shakier, though, when I think about research for a cancer medicine. However, I do think that the other avenues, in-vitro research or computer models, should always be attempted first, even for medical research.

    Would you like to know how to avoid companies that test on animals? First, LUSH is a cosmetics company that is completely anti-animal testing, so that’s a good place to start. Also, there is an online list of companies that still test on animals. Beware: There are quite a lot. Some of the companies have different sectors that don’t test on animals, but this list is evaluating the organization overall.

    Regan Lavin is from Long Island, NY. She has several obsessions in her life, with the most important being theatre. She lives to be onstage and is lucky enough to take acting classes every Saturday in NYC. She spends her summers at the best theatre camp in the world in upstate NY. Last summer, she discovered a new passion...spinning fire. Hobbies are extra special when they require you to wet your hair, wear fire resistant clothing, and have a spotter on hand in case of emergency. In her downtime, she is flying through Supernatural and countless reruns of How I Met Your Mother. You can reach her at


    Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.