They Sang This Upbeat Christmas Song in an Eerie Minor Key, and the Result Is Chilling

I will never be able to listen to “All I Want for Christmas” the same again. At first I didn’t know how I felt about the almost sinister sound, but the song definitely grew on me as I kept listening. “All I Want for Christmas” is a song I’ve enjoyed every now again, but I will now be listening to this version all the time.

I will definitely be looking for more covers where artists have changed a song to a minor key. It gives the song a whole new feel and makes it a brand new experience. Chase Holfelder and Kurt Hugo Schneider have outdone themselves.

Share with us some of your favorite holiday covers, and we may feature them!

You can send them to, or you can share in the comments section below!

Literary Editor/Copy Editor/Managing Editor Briana Bailey has a passion and appreciation for art, including music, writing, photography, and drawing. Her love for reading is why she wishes to one day copy edit novels. Yes, this means she is one of those people who really likes grammar. No, she is not one of those people who corrects other people's grammar when they talk.  (Don't believe her?  Email her at


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.